What’s More Important: Lower Home Prices or Mortgage Rates?

What’s More Important: Lower Home Prices or Mortgage Rates?

July 31st, 2019 | Purchasing a Home, Interest Rates

When buying a home, there are several factors that affect how much mortgage you can afford. Two of the most important are the property prices and current mortgage interest rates. Is it better to search for the absolute lowest rate or is it more helpful to choose a less-expensive home? Here’s how the two factors are related and how to make the right choice.

Mortgage Rate/Home Price Relationship

Since higher mortgage rates make homebuying more expensive for buyers, you might think that home prices would tend to fall during high rate climates in order to compensate for those costs. Unfortunately, that is not always (or even usually!) the case. There have been many instances over the past 40 years when interest rates have dramatically spiked (more than 2% in less than a year’s time) and home prices have continued to see strong upward movement. For example, back in April 1999 mortgage interest rates on 30-year fixed rate loans averaged 6.92% but jumped up to 8.52% by May 2000. Over that same period home prices skyrocketed 10.9%.

Historical data suggests that there is not much correlation between home prices and interest rates at all. Both components are affected by the general strength of the economy, more than each other. If the economy is booming, rates will likely increase to temper inflation, but house prices will rise to keep up with the pace of inflation or because there are more buyers with secure jobs and growing wages.

Mortgage Cost Scenarios

It can be difficult to know when the right time is to buy. You may be watching to see if interest rates are falling or if home prices are likely to rise in the next few months. Trying to time the market just right is almost impossible. It is best to buy when you can comfortably afford the payments, instead of waiting for a magic market moment.

For example, say you decide to buy a $200,000 home when the average interest rate is 4.5%. If you contribute a 20% down payment ($40,000), your monthly payments would be $811 and your total interest costs over the life of the loan would be $131,851.

But what if you wait a year and rates rise to 5% while the property price slips to $190,000.  Your 20% down payment would fall to $38,000 but your monthly payment would rise to $816. Over the course of the loan you would spend $141,749 in interest, $10,000 more than in the first example.

In these situations, it seems the interest rate is a bigger influence on your overall costs, but there are several more things to consider. Buying a less-expensive home, can bring down your down payment and for many first-time buyers that difference in upfront cash can be huge. If the down payment rises too high because of home price, some buyers can be squeezed out of the market.

It is also important to note that is not possible to change your home price once the sale is final, but it is possible to change your rate through refinancing. Buying a less-expensive home with a higher rate could pay off if you are able to refinance into better terms in the future.

And of course, buyers should consider how long they plan to stay in the home. Most homeowners move within 10 years of purchasing. Higher interest rates are easier to stomach if you are only going to be making those payments for a few years.

When it comes to deciding whether to look for the lowest home price or the lowest rate, which one is more important will depend on your personal situation. We can help you figure out which one will better help you afford homeownership.

Please visit our Disclosures page for more details for all loan types.


Leave a Comment

Contact Us

Not readable? Change text.

American Pacific Mortgage

(NMLS# 301003)
Company NMLS# 1850

1001 W. Tehachapi Blvd., Ste A100,
Tehachapi, California 93561
Phone: 661-822-5523

BRE 012163368 / 01215943 | NMLS 301003
Licensed by the Department of Business Oversight under the CRMLA. NMLS Consumer Access Link
AZ Corp BK 0906702

  • Licensed by the Department of Business Oversight under the California Residential Mortgage Lending Act|Licensed by the Dept. of Business Oversight under the CRMLA
  • Corp BK 0906702

© 2020 American Pacific Mortgage Corporation. For informational purposes only. No guarantee of accuracy is expressed or implied. Programs shown may not include all options or pricing structures. Rates, terms, programs and underwriting policies subject to change without notice. This is not an offer to extend credit or a commitment to lend. All loans subject to underwriting approval. Some products may not be available in all states and restrictions may apply. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Search Our Site

American Pacific Mortgage Corporation, Real Estate Loans, Tehachapi, CA